User Rating 0.0
Total Usage 1 times
Is this tool helpful?

Your feedback helps us improve.

About

Medical professionals and anthropologists historically relied on the Broca index to estimate ideal body weight before Body Mass Index became the standard. Paul Broca developed this method in 1871 for quick usage in clinical settings where complex calculation was impractical. The formula assumes a linear relationship between height and weight that simplifies patient assessment. Modern applications often utilize the Brugsch adaptation to correct for height extremes. This adjusted version applies different subtraction constants based on specific height tiers. Reliability decreases significantly for very tall or very short individuals due to the scaling limitations of linear equations. Users frequently consult this metric to understand historical weight expectations versus modern obesity guidelines.

broca index ideal weight brugsch formula anthropometry bmi comparison

Formulas

The standard Broca calculation uses a simple subtraction logic. The Brugsch variant introduces conditional branching based on height H in centimeters.

{
H 100 if H < 165H 105 if 165 H 175H 110 if H > 175

For the original Broca method applied to women generally involves a further reduction.

Wfemale (H 100) × 0.85

Reference Data

Height Range (cm)Original Broca FormulaBrugsch ModificationResult Difference (180cm)
< 165H 100H 1000 kg
165 to 175H 100H 1055 kg
> 175H 100H 11010 kg
GeneralH 100Variable ConstantsVaries
WomenH 100 15%N/ALower
Metric UnitskgkgNone
AccuracyLow for TallModerateImprovement
Origin Year18711960sEra Shift

Frequently Asked Questions

BMI accounts for mass relative to height squared. Broca relies strictly on height minus a constant. This causes Broca to overestimate ideal weight for short individuals and underestimate it for tall individuals unless the Brugsch correction is applied.
Brugsch serves as a heuristic adjustment rather than a rigorous biostatistical model. It corrects the linear error of the original formula but lacks the body composition data found in DEXA scans or modern anthropometry.
No. This formula ignores body composition entirely. A bodybuilder and a sedentary person of the same height receive the exact same target weight. This makes it a poor tool for athletes.
Paul Broca was a French physician and anatomist best known for his work on the speech center of the brain. He developed this index during the Franco-Prussian War to quickly assess soldiers for service eligibility.